Mr. Orivo
The mind

Why Being Alone Feels Like Such a Relief

Being alone turns down bad feelings and good ones too. Research suggests it helps only when you choose it. Why "I'm an introvert" is not the full answer.

The film plays here on the page · 9:37

Somebody asked you to come out this week and you said you were busy. Were you busy, or did you want to be at home?

When you got home and shut the door, what did you feel? For most people it is relief, like putting a bag down.

You have probably been told you are an introvert and that people drain your battery. It is a tidy answer. The research points to something else.

What being alone does

Researchers put people in a room by themselves with no phone, no book and nothing to do, then measured how they felt.

Being alone lowered the strong bad feelings, such as anger and worry. It also lowered the strong good feelings, such as excitement and joy. This is called a deactivation effect. It turns the volume down on everything.

If your days are loud, quiet feels like medicine, and it does work. But it works like a dimmer switch. It does not fix the room. It dims it, and a room can be dimmed too far.

The same evening, two results

Two people spend the same evening alone. One comes out rested. The other comes out worse.

The difference is not how long they were alone, and it is not whether they like people. It is whether they chose it.

Time alone that you chose goes with feeling better and less lonely. Time alone that happened to you goes the other way.

Researchers also tested whether introverts enjoy solitude more. Being an introvert did not predict it. What did was autonomy: acting from what you want and not from pressure or fear.

So ask honestly. Are you going home because you want to, or because being out costs you something?

Where it often starts

Researchers study something quiet called emotional neglect. Nobody has to be cruel for it to happen. You can be fed, clothed and taken to school.

What is missing is smaller. You were upset and nobody asked why. Or you said it and it was not taken seriously.

A child cannot leave and cannot change the house. So the child stops asking. Asking cost more than it paid. That was a good answer, for that house, at that age.

The rule you stopped testing

Most people can name a day: a broken promise, or a secret that was passed on. The brain files it as proof of a rule. People leave, so do not hand them the rope.

After that you watch for small signs, such as a slow reply or a change of tone. Researchers call this being sensitive to rejection. You see it coming, so you go first. You get quiet, get busy and cancel.

Nothing bad happens, which seems to prove you were right. But you left before there was anything to test.

Why work feels safe

If needing people did not work, you needed something that did. Work has rules. Effort goes in and results come out. It does not depend on anybody's mood and it never leaves.

So you become driven. Some of that is real discipline. Some of it is a door being held shut. The real target is not a number. It is never having to ask anybody for anything.

What it costs

For a long time, very little. That is why you kept it. The bill comes later.

  • The dimmer goes too far. Good things start to land flat. Not sad. Flat.
  • The skill gets rusty. Closeness takes practice. Without it, staying home gets easier again.
  • The wanting does not switch off. Being alone protects you from being let down. It does not stop you wanting people.

What helps

Liking your own company is not a problem. The research does not say be alone less. It says make sure you are choosing it.

  • Before you cancel, ask: am I going towards something or away from something?
  • Make the return small. One person, one hour, somewhere you can leave.
  • Notice the going-first move. You do not have to stop. Just notice.
  • If it feels heavy, say it once, out loud, to one person you trust.

The short answer

You are not broken. You learned something that worked and you kept it. Keep the quiet. Choose it on purpose.

This is the written version of a Mr. Orivo film. It is made to explain and to make you curious. It is not medical, legal or financial advice.

Mr. Orivo

A doctor who reads the research, then draws it. Illustrated films and articles on history, the human body, the mind and money.

Keep reading

All articles →